Bunnahabhain Toiteach A Dhà
- Caskable score 76/100
- About £48 (70 cl)
- 46.3% ABV
- Scotland
A soft, sherried, peated malt that scores six points higher for £4 less.

Kilchoman Sanaig is the sherried sibling of Machir Bay, and it tastes like the island with a warm blanket on. This Kilchoman Sanaig review is about a 46% Islay malt that costs about £52, tastes of gentle peat smoke, dried fruit and toffee with a trace of sea air, and is a smoky, rich and rather comforting dram.
I like it more than I expected. The sherry gives a young peated malt some real depth, and it takes the rough edges off a spirit that can be a little raw. It is a good whisky, and not a bargain.
Kilchoman is a farm distillery on the west coast of Islay, founded in 2005, and it is one of the island’s newest and smallest. The Kilchoman distillery grows some of its own barley and makes a lightly to moderately peated spirit.
Sanaig is bottled at 46% with no age statement, and it is matured in a mix of ex-bourbon and ex-Oloroso sherry casks, so check the label on your bottle. UK prices I found ran from about £48 to £58, with the distillery’s own shop at £48.25, so I use about £52. Peat explained covers the smoke, and the Kilchoman Machir Bay is the standard bottle to compare it with.
A smoky fruit cake on a windy beach, a spoon of toffee sauce and a pinch of sea salt.
The nose is smoky and sweet, with gentle peat, dried fruit and toffee, then a little vanilla, a hint of spice and a trace of sea air. It smells warm, young and lively, with the sherry adding a dark sweetness.
On the palate it is smoky and rich, with dark fruit, spice and a creamy middle, then a little toffee, a hint of salt and a firm oak. The 46% gives it a good body, and the texture is soft and slightly oily. The sherry rounds out the smoke, and the youth still shows.
The finish is medium to long, with smoke, oak and a lingering sweetness. It is warm, dry and rather pleasant.
A few drops of water bring out the dried fruit and soften the spice, and I think it is better for it. It also gets sweeter as it sits, and the toffee comes forward. At 46% it takes water well, and a patient pour pays off.
Neat, with a few drops of water, in a tulip glass. It is a very good sipper and a gentle introduction to peated whisky with some sweetness. It makes a good Old Fashioned, where the smoke and the sherry work with the bitters.
It goes well with smoked cheese, dark chocolate and a cold evening. It is a good gift for somebody who likes sherried whisky and would like to try a smoky one.
At about £52 it scores 70. Kilchoman Machir Bay scores 63 at about £45, which is seven points lower for £7 less. Ardbeg 10 scores 72 at about £45, two points better for £7 less. Port Charlotte 10 scores 75 at about £60, and Bunnahabhain Toiteach A Dhà scores 76 at about £48.
So Sanaig is a decent smoky malt at a price where several rivals do better. It beats Machir Bay by seven points for £7 more, which is a good trade, and the Ardbeg and the Toiteach A Dhà beat it for less. I would buy it if I wanted a farm-distillery bottle, and I would take the Port Charlotte if I wanted a better one.
Kilchoman is one of the few distilleries in Scotland that grows barley, malts it and distils it on the same site. It is a romantic idea, and the whisky is young, lively and a little rough, which is part of its charm.
Sanaig uses sherry casks to smooth that youth. The dark fruit and toffee soften the peat, and the result is a more rounded whisky than Machir Bay. It still tastes young, and it tastes better for the sherry.
If you like the idea of the place, this is the bottle that makes the best case for it. If you want a more polished peated malt, the others in the comparison list are a safer bet.
Four more bottles, from the better buys to the standard Kilchoman.
A soft, sherried, peated malt that scores six points higher for £4 less.
A bold, complex Islay malt that scores two points higher for £7 less.
A big, creamy, heavily peated Islay malt that scores five points higher for £8 more.
The farm distillery’s standard bottle, seven points lower for £7 less.
Kilchoman Sanaig is smoky, sherried, toffeed and young, a farm-distillery malt that improves on its sibling. It is a fair bottle at a firm price, and the Bunnahabhain Toiteach A Dhà is the better buy.
Caskable score: 70 out of 100.
Gentle peat smoke, dried fruit, toffee and a trace of sea air
Smoky and rich, with dark fruit, spice and a creamy middle
Medium to long, with smoke, oak and a lingering sweetness
A richer, sherry-touched, gently smoky Islay malt that is better than Machir Bay and costs a bit more.
Thomas Grønvold is the founder of Caskable and a whisky enthusiast who believes the best way to learn about whisky is simply to drink it, compare it, and stay curious. From supermarket favourites to bottles from distilleries around the world, he writes about what he actually tastes and experiences, without pretending you need to be an expert to enjoy a good dram.
View profile →