Aberlour 12 Double Cask Matured
- Caskable score 81/100
- About £38 (70 cl)
- 40% ABV
- Scotland
A double-cask Speyside malt that scores six points higher for the same money.

Aberfeldy 12 is the malt that sits at the heart of Dewar’s, and it tastes like what a jar of heather honey would be if somebody had taught it manners. This Aberfeldy 12 review is about a 40% Highland malt that costs about £38, tastes of honey, malt and a little orchard fruit, and is a soft, waxy, easy dram that has been hiding behind a bigger brand for a century.
I like it a great deal for a whisky that makes so little fuss. It has a gentle, rounded sweetness that I find very hard to dislike, and it makes a sensible, comfortable bottle for a normal evening. It is not a showy malt, and I am quite fond of that.
Aberfeldy sits in the Perthshire town of the same name, on the Pitilie Burn, and it was built in 1896 by John Dewar & Sons to give their blend a malt heart. It is now owned by Bacardi, and most of what it makes still disappears into Dewar’s. The Aberfeldy distillery has a visitor centre and a habit of talking about honey, which is fair, because the whisky tastes of it.
The 12 is the core bottle, bottled at 40% and matured mostly in ex-bourbon casks. It is a soft, unpeated malt with a waxy texture, and it is the single malt version of the style that gives Dewar’s 12 its backbone. If you have ever wondered what the malt in a good blend tastes like on its own, this is a clean, honest way to find out.
A spoon of heather honey, a slice of ripe pear and a warm beeswax candle.
The nose is soft and sweet, with heather honey, malt and orchard fruit, then a little vanilla and a faint waxiness. It smells clean, gentle and rather pretty, with a floral lift that I find very appealing.
On the palate it is smooth and rounded, with honey, vanilla and a little malt, then a hint of spice and a soft oak. The body is light to medium at 40%, and the texture is waxy and slightly oily. It is sweet without being cloying, and the wax gives it more shape than the strength would suggest.
The finish is medium, with honey, oak and a faint nuttiness. It is warm, clean and quietly satisfying.
A few drops of water bring out the pear and soften the oak, and I think it is better for it. It also gets sweeter as it sits, and the honey comes forward. At 40% it does not take much water, and a light hand is the right one.
Neat, with a splash of water, or on the rocks. It is a very good easy sipper and a lovely aperitif malt. It makes a pleasant highball with soda and a slice of lemon, and an acceptable Old Fashioned, though the delicacy gets lost.
It goes well with a soft cheese, a baked apple and a quiet evening. It is a very good gift for somebody who likes honeyed whisky and wants something a little more thoughtful than a famous blend.
At about £38 it scores 75. Glenlivet 12 scores 75 at about £36, the same score for £2 less. Glen Grant 12 scores 74 at about £35. Dewar’s 12 scores 74 at about £28, and Aberlour 12 Double Cask scores 81 at about £38.
So the Aberfeldy is a fair, honest malt at a fair price. The Aberlour is six points better for the same money, and the Dewar’s blend is almost as good for £10 less. I would buy the Aberfeldy for the honey and the waxy texture, and I would not feel that I had been taken.
Most of Aberfeldy’s whisky is made to be blended, and it is a big part of why Dewar’s tastes the way it does. The honeyed, waxy character gives a blend a soft centre, and it is the reason a bottle of Dewar’s 12 tastes rounder than its price suggests. Drinking the malt on its own is a lovely way to see where the blend gets its sweetness.
That is the real value of a bottle like this. It is a single malt with a clear job, and it does it well. It is not the most complex Highland malt, and it is one of the easiest to like, and a whisky that is easy to like at a sensible price has a good claim on a shelf.
Four more bottles, from the better buy to the blend with the same heart.
A double-cask Speyside malt that scores six points higher for the same money.
A fresh, fruity Speyside malt at about the same price.
The blend that uses it, honeyed and £10 cheaper.
A pale, garden-fresh Speyside malt for £3 less.
Aberfeldy 12 is honeyed, waxy, soft and very easy to like, a Highland malt with a gentle charm. It is a fair buy at a fair price, and the Aberlour 12 is the better value.
Caskable score: 75 out of 100.
Heather honey, malt and a little orchard fruit
Soft and waxy, with honey, vanilla and a little spice
Medium, with honey, oak and a faint nuttiness
A honeyed, gentle Highland malt that is better than the Dewar's label suggests.
Thomas Grønvold is the founder of Caskable and a whisky enthusiast who believes the best way to learn about whisky is simply to drink it, compare it, and stay curious. From supermarket favourites to bottles from distilleries around the world, he writes about what he actually tastes and experiences, without pretending you need to be an expert to enjoy a good dram.
View profile →