The Balvenie 12 DoubleWood
- Caskable score 83/100
- About £48 (70 cl)
- 40% ABV
- Scotland
A honeyed, sherry-finished malt that scores four points higher for £26 less.

Balblair 15 is the one where the distillery stops being tidy and starts being generous, and it tastes like the twelve after a very good dinner. This Balblair 15 Year Old review is about a 46% Highland malt that costs about £74, tastes of toffee, dried fruit and orange with a warm spice, and is a rich, rounded and polished dram.
I like it a great deal. It has the freshness of the twelve with a lot more weight and sweetness, and it feels like a whisky that has been given its time. I find the price ambitious, and I find that the whisky earns most of it.
Balblair is a Highland distillery at Edderton in Ross-shire, owned by Inver House Distillers, and the Balblair distillery has been making whisky since 1790. The 15 is bottled at 46% with a fifteen-year age statement, and it is matured in a mix of ex-bourbon and ex-sherry casks, so check the label for the exact recipe on the bottle in your hand.
The price on the major UK listing I found was about £74, with some shops higher and some running offers. The step up from the Balblair 12 is clear, with more depth from the sherry wood and a rounder texture from the extra age. It is a good example of a whisky where fifteen years makes a real difference.
A toffee apple, a strip of orange peel and a pinch of cinnamon on warm toast.
The nose is rich and sweet, with toffee, dried fruit and orange, then a little vanilla and a gentle spice. It smells warm, round and mature, with the freshness of the twelve still in the background.
On the palate it is smooth and full, with toffee, orange and dried fruit, then a little cinnamon, a hint of nuts and a soft oak. The 46% gives it real body, and the texture is silky and a little oily. The sherry is a gentle layer, and the fruit is generous and clean.
The finish is long and warm, with spice, oak and dried fruit. It is rich, clean and rather satisfying.
A few drops of water bring out the orange and soften the toffee, and I think it is better for it. It also gets richer as it sits, and the dried fruit comes forward. At 46% it takes water well, and a patient pour pays off.
Neat, with a few drops of water, in a good glass. It is a very good sipper and a lovely after-dinner whisky. It makes a rich Old Fashioned, where the toffee and the orange are a natural fit, and a very good Manhattan.
It goes well with a fruit cake, a mild blue cheese and a long evening. It is a very good gift for somebody who likes the twelve and wants something richer.
At about £74 it scores 79. Balblair 12 scores 77 at about £46, which is two points lower for £28 less. Glenmorangie Lasanta 12 scores 79 at about £45, the same score for £29 less. Balvenie 12 DoubleWood scores 83 at about £48, and Dalwhinnie 15 scores 80 at about £50.
So the 15 is a lovely whisky at a high price. The Balvenie is four points better for £26 less, and the Dalwhinnie 15 is a point better for £24 less. I would buy the 15 for the richness and the strength, and I would be honest that the competition is fierce.
The jump from twelve to fifteen at Balblair is partly age and partly wood. The sherry casks add toffee, dried fruit and a little spice, and they turn a fresh, citrusy malt into a rounder, sweeter, more serious one. It is a very clear lesson in what different casks can do.
The result is a whisky with the same underlying spirit and a quite different feel. I find the balance good, with the freshness preserved and the sweetness added, and I think it is a very nice way to stretch a Highland style. I wish the price were a little kinder.
Four more bottles, from the better buys to the sibling.
A honeyed, sherry-finished malt that scores four points higher for £26 less.
A soft, honeyed, gently smoky malt that scores a point higher for £24 less.
A sherry-finished Highland malt with the same score for £29 less.
The twelve-year-old, fresher and £28 cheaper.
Balblair 15 is toffeed, orangey, rounded and beautifully made, a richer Highland malt with real polish. It is a good bottle at a high price, and the Balvenie 12 is the better buy.
Caskable score: 79 out of 100.
Toffee, dried fruit, orange and warm spice
Rich and rounded, with toffee, orange and gentle oak
Long and warm, with spice, oak and dried fruit
A richer, deeper Balblair with real polish, held back only by the price.
Thomas Grønvold is the founder of Caskable and a whisky enthusiast who believes the best way to learn about whisky is simply to drink it, compare it, and stay curious. From supermarket favourites to bottles from distilleries around the world, he writes about what he actually tastes and experiences, without pretending you need to be an expert to enjoy a good dram.
View profile →