×
caskable
×
Review

Glen Garioch 12 Review

Caskable score77 / 100
Glen Garioch 12 Review
Region
Scotland
Age
12 years
ABV
48
Cask
Ex-bourbon and ex-sherry casks
Price
About £44 (70 cl)

Glen Garioch 12 is a whisky you will mispronounce at least once, and the distillery has had since 1797 to get over it. It is “Geery”, for the record, and this Glen Garioch 12 review is mostly an argument that you should learn it, because what is in the bottle is better than the marketing has any right to allow.

It costs about £44, comes at 48%, and has not been chill-filtered or tinted by a man with a colour chart. In a world of 40% malts that taste like a damp biscuit, that makes it practically radical. It is not a spectacular whisky. It is an honest one, and honest whisky has become oddly hard to find.

Barley, basically

Glen Garioch sits in Oldmeldrum, in the Garioch, which Aberdeenshire calls its granary, and that is not decoration. Barley is the whole point of the place. In 2021 the distillery put its own floor maltings back, so a quarter or so of the barley is now spread, turned and malted on site by people with shovels. Almost nobody does that any more because it is slow, expensive and a pain, which is exactly why I like it.

Suntory owns it, by way of Morrison Bowmore, so there is money behind the place, but it still feels like a farm that learned to distil. It lost its water in 1968, shut up, and was rescued by a spring found on a neighbouring farm in 1972, now called the Silent Spring. If that does not make you root for a whisky, nothing will.

It is unpeated these days, which matters if you have read about the old smoky vintages and turned up expecting a bonfire. You will not get one. What you get is the tidy, malty end of the Highlands with a little sherry in the background.

In the glass

Short version: honey, malt, a bit of fruit and no nonsense. The long version follows, for the people who like to be thorough.

The nose is warm barley biscuit and honey, with baked apple and a faint nuttiness I put down to the sherry casks. Underneath there is something earthy, like a barn in October, which sounds like an insult and is not. A few drops of water and the fruit goes sweeter while the oak sensibly keeps out of the way.

On the tongue it is creamy and properly oily, with malt, pear, a bit of toffee and a slow build of pepper. That 48% is doing a lot of the work. A 40% bottle would taste like a rumour of this. There is dried fruit from the sherry, but it never turns into a sherry bomb, and I would have been cross if it had.

The finish is medium to long, warm and drying, malt and oak with a last smear of honey. It finishes like it means it. You want another sip, not a glass of water, which is more than I can say for plenty of whiskies at twice the price.

How I drink it

Neat, tulip glass, a few drops of water, five minutes of leaving it alone. That is the whole ritual and it is not negotiable. Ice is a crime here: it kills the honey and flattens the texture. One big cube on a hot evening is forgivable. Two is a cry for help.

It goes with hard cheese, oatcakes and dark chocolate, and it makes a perfectly sturdy Old Fashioned, though that feels like hiring a lorry to move a chair. The only trick worth knowing is to read the box: if it says non-chill-filtered and 48%, that is the stuff you want.

The price court

At about £44 it is playing in a hard league. Highland Park 12 scores 81 at about £43 and does it with more polish. Glenfarclas 12 scores 80 at £48 and has the sherry weight Garioch only hints at. That is why this one sits at 77: better made than its name suggests, but short of that last gear the best £45 bottles have.

What it has instead is strength, texture and honesty. No colouring, no chill filtration, a spirit that tastes of barley. If you value that over a stag on the label, it is good value. If you want a story for dinner guests, buy something with a stag on it and be ready to pay for the stag.

Fair warning: nothing here is a bargain, exactly. It is just priced like an adult, and the extra tenner over a supermarket 40% buys a noticeable amount of body.

Other bottles to argue with

Four neighbours worth a glass before you decide. None of them beats it in every way, which is the point of having more than one.

Verdict

Glen Garioch 12 is honest, malty and properly made, with a texture that earns its 48%. It will not change your life, and I suspect it is not trying to. At about £44 it is a very decent everyday Highland malt, and a better way to spend that money than most things with louder labels.

Caskable score: 77 out of 100.

Advertisement
Your advertisement here? Advertise with Caskable
Tasting notes
Nose

Honey, malt, baked apple and a little vanilla

Palate

Creamy and honeyed, with malt, pear and gentle spice

Finish

Medium to long, warm and drying, with malt and oak

The verdict

A malty, honeyed everyday Highland malt with real texture at 48%.

Enjoyed this review? Pass it on.
Thomas Gronvold
Thomas Gronvold

Thomas Grønvold is the founder of Caskable and a whisky enthusiast who believes the best way to learn about whisky is simply to drink it, compare it, and stay curious. From supermarket favourites to bottles from distilleries around the world, he writes about what he actually tastes and experiences, without pretending you need to be an expert to enjoy a good dram.

View profile →
Advertisement
Your advertisement here? Advertise with Caskable
Glen Garioch 12
The bottle
Glen Garioch 12
Scotland48% ABV12 years
Check price at retailer
18+ · Affiliate link · Prices may vary
Caskable score
77
out of 100
In this review
    The Caskable Weekly

    One email a week. Whisky worth knowing about.

    New reviews, distillery news and what is worth buying right now. No spam, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

    Read our privacy policy. Your email is used only to send the newsletter.