Glen Garioch 12
- Caskable score 77/100
- About £44 (70 cl)
- 48% ABV
- Scotland
The twelve-year-old, waxier and two points higher for £22 less.

Glen Garioch Virgin Oak is a waxy Highland malt that has been given a lot of fresh wood, and it tastes like a vanilla pod in a toolshed. This Glen Garioch Virgin Oak review is about a 48% malt that costs about £66, tastes of vanilla, coconut and honey with a trace of spice, and is a sweet, spicy and oaky dram.
I like it, with some caveats. The fresh oak adds sweetness and spice, and it also pushes the distillery’s waxy character into the background. It is a good whisky, and I would pay less for it and more for the twelve.
Glen Garioch is in Oldmeldrum, in Aberdeenshire, in the east Highlands, and it dates from 1797. It belongs to Beam Suntory, and the Glen Garioch distillery makes a waxy, gently smoky spirit that is usually bottled at a good strength.
The Virgin Oak is bottled at 48% with no age statement, and the name points to maturation or finishing in fresh, unused oak. The exact process is not clearly published, so check the label. The only UK price I found was about £66 at one retailer, so I use that and flag it as uncertain. Cask finishes explained covers the idea, and the Glen Garioch Founder’s Reserve is the standard bottle.
A vanilla pod and a stick of cinnamon in a freshly planed pine box, with a spoon of honey.
The nose is sweet and woody, with vanilla, coconut and honey, then a trace of spice, a hint of baked fruit and a faint waxy note. It smells warm, creamy and a little sawdusty, with the oak very much in charge.
On the palate it is sweet and spicy, with vanilla, baked fruit and a creamy middle, then a little coconut, a hint of pepper and a firm, drying oak. The 48% gives it real body, and the texture is thick and smooth. The sweetness is generous, and the oak sets the tone.
The finish is medium to long, with oak, spice and a lingering sweetness. It is warm, dry and rather sweet.
A few drops of water bring out the baked fruit and soften the spice, and I think it is better for it. It also gets creamier as it sits, and the vanilla comes forward. At 48% it takes water well, and a patient pour pays off.
Neat, with a few drops of water, in a tulip glass. It is a very good sipper for somebody who likes sweet, oaky whisky, and I would not put it over ice. It makes a rich Old Fashioned, where the vanilla and the spice are a natural fit.
It goes well with a vanilla dessert, a mild cheese and a quiet evening. It is a good gift for somebody who likes bourbon and wants to try a Scotch with a similar sweetness.
At about £66 it scores 75. Glen Garioch 12 scores 77 at about £44, which is two points better for £22 less. Glen Garioch Founder’s Reserve scores 75 at about £41, the same score for £25 less. Highland Park 12 scores 81 at about £43, and Dalwhinnie 15 scores 80 at about £50.
So the Virgin Oak is a good whisky at a high price. It ties the Founder’s Reserve for £25 more, and the twelve, the Highland Park and the Dalwhinnie all beat it for much less. I would buy the Virgin Oak only out of curiosity about the oak, and I would be honest about that.
Most whisky is matured in casks that have held something else first, usually bourbon or sherry. Those used casks give up their flavour slowly and gently. A virgin oak cask is new wood with nothing in it, and it gives up vanilla, coconut and spice much faster and more forcefully.
That is the whole story of this bottle. The sweetness and the spice come from the fresh wood, and the waxy character of the spirit is pushed into the background. It is an interesting experiment and a slightly one-note result.
If you like bourbon, you will probably like it. If you value what makes Glen Garioch different from other Highland malts, the other bottles in the range show it better.
Four more bottles, from the better buys to the siblings.
The twelve-year-old, waxier and two points higher for £22 less.
The standard strong, waxy bottle that ties it for £25 less.
A honeyed, lightly smoky malt that scores six points higher for £23 less.
A soft, honeyed Highland malt that scores five points higher for £16 less.
Glen Garioch Virgin Oak is sweet, spicy, creamy and oaky, a Highland malt that trades its character for vanilla. It is a fair bottle at a high price, and the Glen Garioch 12 is the better buy.
Caskable score: 75 out of 100.
Vanilla, coconut, honey and a trace of spice
Sweet and spicy, with vanilla, baked fruit and a creamy middle
Medium to long, with oak, spice and a lingering sweetness
A sweet, spicy, oak-led Highland malt that is good and a bit pricey.
Thomas Grønvold is the founder of Caskable and a whisky enthusiast who believes the best way to learn about whisky is simply to drink it, compare it, and stay curious. From supermarket favourites to bottles from distilleries around the world, he writes about what he actually tastes and experiences, without pretending you need to be an expert to enjoy a good dram.
View profile →