Highland Park 12
- Caskable score 81/100
- About £43 (70 cl)
- 40% ABV
- Scotland
A honeyed, lightly smoky malt that scores seven points higher for £37 less.

Oban 14 is the harbour malt: a small distillery squeezed into a west-coast town, making whisky in a place where you can smell the fish suppers from the stillhouse. This Oban 14 review is about a 43% West Highland malt that costs about £80, tastes of caramelised pineapple, sea salt and a touch of smoke, and is a very pretty, slightly strange whisky that I like and cannot easily recommend at that price.
It is the kind of dram that makes a good argument for itself in the first sip and a worse one at the till. I think it is lovely. I also think £80 is a lot of money for lovely.
Oban is in the harbour town of the same name on Scotland’s west coast, owned by Diageo. It dates from 1794, which makes it one of the older distilleries in the country, and it is also one of the smallest, with just two stills. That small scale gives the whisky a hand-made reputation, even if a lot of its fame now comes from being a Diageo Classic Malt. The Oban distillery is squeezed between the cliffs and the water, and visiting it is a pleasure.
The 14 is bottled at 43%, and it sits in the West Highland style: a little fruit, a little salt, a trace of smoke. If you want to understand why Highland covers so many styles, the beginner’s guide to Highland whisky has the answer. Oban is a good example of the coastal side of the region, and a useful reminder that the map of Scotch is rather more complicated than the labels suggest.
Caramelised pineapple, a sea-wet pebble and a pinch of nutmeg.
The nose has a surprising amount of tropical fruit: caramelised pineapple and lychee, with cinnamon and nutmeg underneath, then orange, peach and pear, a touch of sea salt and a faint wisp of smoke. It smells bright, sweet and a little exotic, with a rather lovely coastal lift.
On the palate it is smooth and medium-bodied, with orange, honey and malt, then a little salt, a hint of smoke and a gentle spice. The 43% gives it a good weight, and the texture is slightly oily. The balance between the sweet fruit and the dry smoke is very good, and it feels thoughtful.
The finish is medium to long, with oak, a little smoke and a lingering salty sweetness. It is clean, warm and quietly satisfying.
A few drops of water bring out the pineapple and calm the salt, and I think it is better for it. It also opens up as it sits, and the smoke steps further back. This is a whisky that rewards a slow glass and a quiet corner.
Neat, with a few drops of water, in a good glass. It is a very good sipper, and I would not put it over ice. It makes a very good aperitif malt and a lovely one for a quiet evening by the sea, or by a window with a bit of imagination.
It goes well with smoked salmon, oysters and a mild cheese. It is a lovely gift for somebody who likes coastal whiskies, and a good bottle to take to the sea.
At about £80 it scores 74. Talisker 10 scores 70 at about £42, which is four points lower and £38 cheaper. Highland Park 12 scores 81 at about £43, which is seven points better for £37 less. Old Pulteney 12 scores 73 at about £38, and Clynelish 14 scores 72 at about £55.
That is the problem. The Oban is a good whisky, and the Highland Park is a better one for about half the money. The coastal alternatives are cheaper and nearly as good. I would buy the Oban if I wanted the pineapple and the harbour, and I would not buy it if I wanted value.
Oban has only two stills, and that is a very small amount of production for a Classic Malt. The distillery cannot make much, and the demand for its whisky is high, and the price reflects that. It is a classic example of a small distillery with a big brand.
The scale also shapes the whisky. A small still gives more contact between the vapour and the copper, and a longer, slower run. It is part of the reason the Oban 14 tastes layered and a bit odd, with a mix of fruit and salt and smoke that you do not often find in one glass. I find that charming, and I find the price a bit harsh.
Four more bottles, from the better buys to the other coastal malts.
A honeyed, lightly smoky malt that scores seven points higher for £37 less.
A peppery, maritime Skye malt at about half the price.
A briny, coconut-sweet northern malt for £42 less.
A waxy, coastal Highland malt with more weight.
Oban 14 is fruity, salty, gently smoky and rather beautiful, a coastal malt of real charm. It is expensive for what it is, and the Highland Park is the better buy.
Caskable score: 74 out of 100.
Caramelised pineapple and lychee with orange, peach, a touch of salt and a hint of peat smoke.
Apricot, peach and toffee with marmalade and sea salt. Sweet, salty and fruity, roughly in that order.
Medium to long, ending bright and slightly acidic, with toasty oak and spice.
Fruity, coastal and faintly smoky. Charming whisky with a pricing problem.
Thomas Grønvold is the founder of Caskable and a whisky enthusiast who believes the best way to learn about whisky is simply to drink it, compare it, and stay curious. From supermarket favourites to bottles from distilleries around the world, he writes about what he actually tastes and experiences, without pretending you need to be an expert to enjoy a good dram.
View profile →