Highland Park 12
- Caskable score 81/100
- About £43 (70 cl)
- 40% ABV
- Scotland
The island benchmark, nine points higher for about thirty pounds less.

The Oban Little Bay review is about the cheaper, younger sibling of the Oban 14, which I scored 74 at about £80. Little Bay is 43 per cent, it carries no age statement, and it costs about £72. That is not as cheap as it sounds, because it is a no-age bottle at a price that used to buy an age statement.
The Oban 14 is a lovely malt. I wanted to know whether the Little Bay is a lovely malt too, or a good-looking neighbour.
Oban was founded in 1794 by the Stevenson brothers and is older than the town that grew up around it. It makes its malt on just two stills, and Diageo has owned it since 1997. The Oban page covers the harbour setting, the Classic Malts range and the fruity, coastal house style.
Little Bay is a no-age-statement distillery bottling at 43 per cent, in a 70 cl bottle, and the listing declares added colour. The core range is the 14 Year Old, Little Bay and the Distillers Edition, and my page reports bourbon and Montilla sherry casks for the distillery generally. The cask recipe for this bottling is not stated.
Peach, honey and a hint of salty brioche.
The nose is fruity and gently coastal: ripe peach and orange, with honey and a toasty, bready note like brioche, a little black pepper and a faint breath of sea air. It is warm, soft and very appealing.
The palate is smooth and light to medium, with honey and peach first, then orange and a peppery spice and a little salt. At 43 per cent it is a bit thin, and the flavours are pleasant and clear. It has the house character of the 14 in a lighter, sweeter form.
The finish is short to medium: honey, black pepper, a hint of salt and a clean fade.
Little Bay has the shape of an Oban, which is fruity, coastal and gently peppery. It has less depth and less length than the 14, and it makes up for it with an easy sweetness. It is a pleasant, drinkable malt, and it tastes like something you could drink most evenings. It is the sort of malt that makes a good first single malt for a drinker who finds Highland malts too dry.
It is also a little pricey for what it is. The 14 costs more, and it is the better whisky by a small margin that I would happily pay for.
Neat, with a few drops of water, in a tulip glass. The peach and the honey are lovely when the glass is slightly warm. It would also make a good highball with soda and a slice of orange, though at £72 you may prefer to keep it neat.
At about £72 it scores 72. Oban 14 scores 74 at about £80. Highland Park 12 scores 81 at about £43, and Dalwhinnie 15 scores 80 at about £50. Talisker 10 scores 70 at about £42.
So the Little Bay is two points behind the 14 for eight pounds less, and it loses to the Highland Park and the Dalwhinnie by eight or nine points for twenty to thirty pounds less. It is a nice malt in a bracket that is dominated by better ones.
If you want a fruity, coastal, easy malt at about this price, these four are far better value.
The island benchmark, nine points higher for about thirty pounds less.
Soft, rounded and eight points higher, for about twenty pounds less.
Two points higher, deeper and a little more expensive.
A peppery, maritime malt at about forty-two pounds.
A soft, peachy, honeyed West Highland malt that is easy to like and slightly overpriced. If you want Oban, buy the 14. If you want value, buy a Highland Park.
Caskable score: 72 out of 100.
Ripe peach and orange, honey, brioche, black pepper and a faint breath of sea air.
Smooth and light to medium, honey and peach, orange, peppery spice and a little salt.
Short to medium. Honey, black pepper, a hint of salt and a clean fade.
A soft peachy honeyed Oban that is easy but slightly overpriced.
Thomas Grønvold is the founder of Caskable and a whisky enthusiast who believes the best way to learn about whisky is simply to drink it, compare it, and stay curious. From supermarket favourites to bottles from distilleries around the world, he writes about what he actually tastes and experiences, without pretending you need to be an expert to enjoy a good dram.
View profile →