GlenAllachie 10 Year Old Cask Strength
- Caskable score 81/100
- About £64
- 59.8% ABV
- Scotland
A cask-strength sherried malt, a point higher for twenty-three pounds less.

The Tamdhu Batch Strength review is about the loudest Tamdhu. This one is Batch No 8, sherry cask matured, bottled at 57.5 per cent, and it costs about £87. Batch strength means that the number on the label is whatever the batch came out at, so the next batch will not be the same.
I scored the Tamdhu 12 at 79 and the 15 at 80, both at gentler strengths. I wanted to know whether the extra power makes it better, or just louder.
Tamdhu is the Knockando distillery on the River Spey, rescued from closure by Ian Macleod in 2011 and turned into a sherry-only single malt. The Tamdhu page covers the history and the range, which includes the 10, 12, 15 and 18, Batch Strength and Quercus Alba.
Batch Strength is a recurring release, and the strength varies from batch to batch. This one, Batch No 8, is 57.5 per cent in a 70 cl bottle. If you buy a different batch, the strength and the flavour will move a little, and I would not hold today’s notes against it.
Fig, honeycomb and a spoonful of dried fruit.
The nose is deep and sweet: dried fruit and figs, with honeycomb and vanilla, dark chocolate and a rich, toasty sherry note. At this strength it is concentrated and slightly spirity, and a few drops of water open it into something warm and fruity.
The palate is thick and powerful, with dried fruit and honeycomb up front, then figs, vanilla and a long, spicy oak. At 57.5 per cent it is hot, and with water it softens into a rounded, sherried whisky with a remarkable texture. It is rich without being heavy, and the sherry is well integrated.
The finish is long: dried fruit, honey, dark chocolate and a warming spice that goes on and on.
Strength does for Tamdhu what it does for most good sherried malts: it concentrates everything. The 12 is a lively, sweet and easy whisky. The Batch Strength has the same flavours with far more depth, and I think it is the best way to taste what the distillery does.
It is also a more demanding whisky. You need water, a decent glass and a bit of patience, and in return you get a lot of whisky for the money.
With a splash of water, slowly, in a tulip glass. It is a winter whisky, and it makes a very good after-dinner pour. I would not mix it and I would not add ice. A decent tulip glass makes more difference here than usual, because the concentration of the sherry needs room. I would pour it last. Patience.
At about £87 it scores 80. Tamdhu 15 scores 80 at about £83. GlenAllachie 10 Cask Strength scores 81 at about £64, and GlenDronach 12 scores 82 at about £50. Aberlour A’bunadh scores 72 at about £85.
So the Batch Strength matches the Tamdhu 15 for four pounds more, and it loses to the GlenAllachie by a point for twenty-three pounds more. It beats the A’bunadh clearly. It is excellent, and the GlenAllachie is the better buy.
If you want a strong, sherried Speyside malt, these four are the comparisons I would draw.
A cask-strength sherried malt, a point higher for twenty-three pounds less.
Dark and fruity, two points higher, for about fifty pounds.
The same score at a gentler strength and a similar price.
A strong, sherried Speysider scoring eight points lower at about the same price.
A rich, fig-and-honeycomb, powerfully sherried Speyside malt that is the best Tamdhu I have had in the glass. It is excellent, it varies by batch and the GlenAllachie costs less.
Caskable score: 80 out of 100.
Dried fruit, figs, honeycomb, vanilla, dark chocolate and toasty sherry.
Thick and powerful, dried fruit and honeycomb, figs, vanilla, long spicy oak.
Long. Dried fruit, honey, dark chocolate and a warming spice.
A rich, powerful sherried Tamdhu that is excellent but dearer than the GlenAllachie.
Thomas Grønvold is the founder of Caskable and a whisky enthusiast who believes the best way to learn about whisky is simply to drink it, compare it, and stay curious. From supermarket favourites to bottles from distilleries around the world, he writes about what he actually tastes and experiences, without pretending you need to be an expert to enjoy a good dram.
View profile →