×
caskable
×
Review

Tomintoul 10 Year Old Review

Caskable score66 / 100
Tomintoul 10 Year Old Review
Region
Scotland
Age
10 years
ABV
40
Cask
Not stated
Price
About £39

Tomintoul calls its whisky the Gentle Dram, and this Tomintoul 10 Year Old review has to concede that the slogan is accurate. At 40 per cent, with caramel colouring and a deliberately light style, it is about as gentle as a single malt gets. It costs about £39, which is where the gentleness starts to look like a problem.

Gentle is a fine thing for a whisky to be. It just needs to be gentle and interesting, and I am not sure this manages both.

What the label tells you, and what it hides

Tomintoul is a Speyside distillery in the Ballindalloch area, built in the mid-1960s and now owned by Angus Dundee Distillers, an independent company. The Tomintoul distillery page tells the story. The 10 Year Old is the core bottle, bottled at 40 per cent, and the spec lists added colour.

Caramel colouring is allowed, common and harmless, but it is the sort of detail that tells me the whisky was made to a standard look, not to a standard of flavour. A whisky that does not need to be adjusted usually says so on the label.

Tomintoul 10 tasting notes

Vanilla, apple skin and a rather polite cereal.

The nose is light and sweet: vanilla, honey, green apple, some cereal and a little toffee. There is not much going on, but nothing is wrong either. It reminds me of a clean, young, slightly floral Speysider.

The palate is soft and a bit thin. I get honey and vanilla, a flicker of apple and pear, a little pepper and a malty, biscuity backbone. The texture is light, and the 40 per cent shows. It has just enough flavour to be pleasant and not enough to be memorable.

The finish is short: sweet malt, a little oak and a whisper of spice, gone in a few seconds. It is clean and uncomplicated.

The gentle dram problem

I understand what Tomintoul is aiming for. A whisky for people who find stronger, peatier or more sherried drams too much. There is a real audience for that, and this serves it politely. I would hand it to someone nervous about whisky and they would probably enjoy it.

The trouble is the price. At about £39 you are no longer buying a beginner’s bottle for pocket money. You are buying the same easy style that other distilleries do with more flavour.

How to drink it

A highball is the best use I can find. With soda, ice and a slice of lemon, the vanilla and apple come forward and the thin body stops mattering. Neat it is a fine, quiet glass, though I would not choose it for sitting down with. Of all the Tomintoul marketing, the Gentle Dram line is the most honest thing about it, and I mean that kindly.

Is Tomintoul 10 worth £39?

At about £39 it scores 66. Glen Moray 12 scores 73 at about £40, and Aberfeldy 12 scores 75 at about £38. Glen Grant 10 scores 70 at about £36, and Speyburn 10 scores 68 at about £24.

So there are four lighter Scottish malts that are better or cheaper than this, in several cases both. The Tomintoul is not a failure. It is simply not the one I would pick.

I expect the older Tomintoul bottles, which come with more age and strength, tell a better story, and I will cover them separately.

Four light malts that do it better

If a soft, easy Speyside or Highland malt is what you are after, these four give more for the money.

Verdict

A gentle, pleasant, thin single malt that costs more than gentle whisky should. If you find it on offer, it is a harmless way to spend an evening. At full price, buy the Aberfeldy.

Caskable score: 66 out of 100.

Advertisement
Your advertisement here? Advertise with Caskable
Tasting notes
Nose

Vanilla, honey, green apple, cereal and a little toffee.

Palate

Soft and thin, honey, apple, pear, a little pepper and a biscuity malt backbone.

Finish

Short. Sweet malt, a little oak and a whisper of spice.

The verdict

A light, gentle Speysider that is pleasant but dull, and dearer than the better light malts.

Enjoyed this review? Pass it on.
Thomas Gronvold
Thomas Gronvold

Thomas Grønvold is the founder of Caskable and a whisky enthusiast who believes the best way to learn about whisky is simply to drink it, compare it, and stay curious. From supermarket favourites to bottles from distilleries around the world, he writes about what he actually tastes and experiences, without pretending you need to be an expert to enjoy a good dram.

View profile →
Advertisement
Your advertisement here? Advertise with Caskable
Tomintoul 10 Year Old
The bottle
Tomintoul 10 Year Old
Scotland40% ABV10 years
Check price at retailer
18+ · Affiliate link · Prices may vary
Caskable score
66
out of 100
In this review
    The Caskable Weekly

    One email a week. Whisky worth knowing about.

    New reviews, distillery news and what is worth buying right now. No spam, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

    Read our privacy policy. Your email is used only to send the newsletter.