BenRiach The Twelve
- Caskable score 79/100
- About £50 (70 cl)
- 46% ABV
- Scotland
Triple-distilled fruit and a bit of sherry weight.

This Virginia Distillery Co. Blue Ridge American Single Malt review starts with the stills, because the stills are the strangest part of the story. They are two long-necked copper pots that were bought in Scotland and shipped to a hillside in central Virginia, and they make a spirit that is neither quite Scotch nor quite anything else.
It is about £51, and it is bottled at 46.5 per cent. I wanted to find out whether the Scottish stills had come with a Scottish accent.
The Virginia Distillery was started by George Moore, an Irish-born businessman who bought the site and the stills in 2011, and who died in 2013 before it was finished. The Moore family took it over, and the first whiskies in 2015 were actually Scotch whisky finished in Virginia while the new spirit matured. The Virginia Distillery Co. page has the whole tale, and I recommend it.
The Blue Ridge is the American single malt, and the 46.5 per cent strength sits a little above the Scotch standard. The mash is barley-only, from Midwest malt, and the fermentation and distillation are done in the Scottish style, which is the point.
Green apple, vanilla fudge and a little wet barley.
The nose is bright and fruity: green apple, pear, vanilla fudge and a touch of honey, with a soft cereal note and a trace of cinnamon from the oak. It smells young, in a lively and pleasant way.
The palate is smooth and sweet, with apple and vanilla first, then toffee, a little baking spice and a gentle, grainy malt. The texture is clean and slightly creamy. The oak is light, and it never gets in the way. At 46.5 per cent it is well balanced, and quite easy.
The finish is medium: vanilla, soft spice, a little malt and a clean, slightly dry fade. It is pleasant and not very long.
What I find interesting is that it does not taste like a Speyside copy. The American oak adds sweetness and spice that you do not get from tired refill casks, and the result is somewhere between a young Scotch and a bourbon-matured malt.
It is a very easy dram, and it is not a very deep one. If you want a gentle introduction to American single malt, it is a good one. If you want drama, you will need to look elsewhere.
The distillery also makes finished versions, including port and cider cask bottlings, so the Blue Ridge is the clean baseline for judging them. If the baseline is sound, as it is here, the finishes have something to build on.
Neat or with a drop of water, in a tulip glass. It is a good candidate for an Old Fashioned if you want something lighter than a bourbon, and it takes a highball well.
At about £51 it scores 74. Westland Peated Single Malt scores 73 at about £52, and BenRiach Twelve scores 79 at about £50. Auchentoshan 12 scores 79 at about £38, and Glenmorangie 12 Original scores 75 at about £30.
So the Blue Ridge is fairly priced for an American single malt and dear against the Scotch rivals that beat it. It is worth having if you are curious about the category. It is not the best value.
If you are choosing a gentle, fruity single malt at about fifty pounds, these four are the ones to compare.
Triple-distilled fruit and a bit of sherry weight.
A light, fruity triple-distilled Lowland malt.
A smoky American malt at a similar price.
The classic Highland standard at about thirty pounds.
A bright, soft, easy American single malt made in Scottish stills, with a good story and a fair price. It is a very pleasant start to the category, and not its summit.
Caskable score: 74 out of 100.
Green apple, pear, vanilla fudge, honey and soft cereal.
Smooth and sweet, apple and vanilla, toffee, baking spice and a grainy malt.
Medium. Vanilla, soft spice, a little malt and a clean dry fade.
A bright, soft American single malt from Scottish stills that is pleasant but not exceptional.
Thomas Grønvold is the founder of Caskable and a whisky enthusiast who believes the best way to learn about whisky is simply to drink it, compare it, and stay curious. From supermarket favourites to bottles from distilleries around the world, he writes about what he actually tastes and experiences, without pretending you need to be an expert to enjoy a good dram.
View profile →