×
caskable
×
Review

Westland Peated Single Malt Review

Caskable score73 / 100
Westland Peated Single Malt Review
Region
USA
Age
No age statement
ABV
46
Cask
New American oak
Price
About £52

This Westland Peated Single Malt review is a test of a theory. The theory is that you can make a smoky single malt in Seattle that does not need an apology, and that it can stand next to a Scottish one at about £52.

I went in wanting to like it, and I will tell you at once that I did. I will also tell you what I think it still lacks.

An American single malt with a rulebook

Westland is a Seattle distillery owned by Rémy Cointreau since 2017, and it has been one of the loudest voices for a proper definition of American single malt. The recipe is barley-only, made with a Washington pale malt base and a Belgian saison yeast, distilled in two pot stills and matured in new American oak. The Westland distillery page goes into the stills, the farms and the Garry oak.

The Peated is the smoky expression of the core single malt, bottled at 46 per cent. It is a good place to see what the distillery does, because the smoke is a seasoning on top of a spirit that already has its own accent.

Westland Peated tasting notes

Woodsmoke, red apple and a spoonful of malted milk.

The nose is gentle and fruity: red apple and pear, malted milk, vanilla and a cool, drifting smoke like the aftermath of a campfire. It is more orchard than coast, which is not what I expect from a peated malt.

The palate is soft, a little creamy and quite sweet, with vanilla and fruit first, and then the smoke arrives in the middle, earthy and a little sooty. There is a hint of cinnamon from the new oak, and a touch of dark chocolate. At 46 per cent it is smooth and balanced. It is smoky without being medicinal.

The finish is medium, with ash, vanilla, a light spice and a sweet, mellow fade. The smoke stays quietly at the back.

Smoke without the sea

If I tasted this blind, I would not say Islay. There is no brine, no iodine and none of the tar that Scottish peat tends to carry. The smoke here is drier, woodier and more like a bonfire at the edge of a field. It is a different thing, and I find it refreshing.

The cost of that gentleness is a lack of force. A smoky whisky at £52 has competitors that hit much harder, and anybody who likes Islay will find this a quiet pour.

That makes it a good choice for anyone who finds Scottish peat too medicinal.

How to drink it

Neat in a tulip glass, with a few drops of water to open up the fruit. It also takes a single large cube well. I would not mix it, but a very small splash of soda gives a good smoky long drink if you want one.

Is Westland Peated worth £52?

At about £52 it scores 73. Ardbeg 10 scores 72 at about £45, and Bunnahabhain Toiteach A Dhà scores 76 at about £48. Port Charlotte 10 scores 75 at about £60, and Kilchoman Sanaig scores 70 at about £52.

That is a fair fight, and the Westland holds its own. It is dearer than the Ardbeg and a little behind the Bunnahabhain, and I would still choose it if I wanted something peated that was not Scottish.

Four smoky malts to compare

If it is a peated malt you are after, these four are the ones to put beside the Westland.

Verdict

A gentle, orchard-fruity, woodsmoke-scented American single malt that holds its own with the Scots and does not copy them. I would not mistake it for Islay, and I would not want it to be.

Caskable score: 73 out of 100.

Advertisement
Your advertisement here? Advertise with Caskable
Tasting notes
Nose

Red apple, pear, malted milk, vanilla and drifting woodsmoke.

Palate

Soft and creamy, vanilla and fruit first, earthy sooty smoke in the middle.

Finish

Medium. Ash, vanilla, light spice and a sweet mellow fade.

The verdict

A gentle, orchard-fruity peated American malt that is a worthwhile alternative to Scottish smoke.

Enjoyed this review? Pass it on.
Thomas Gronvold
Thomas Gronvold

Thomas Grønvold is the founder of Caskable and a whisky enthusiast who believes the best way to learn about whisky is simply to drink it, compare it, and stay curious. From supermarket favourites to bottles from distilleries around the world, he writes about what he actually tastes and experiences, without pretending you need to be an expert to enjoy a good dram.

View profile →
Advertisement
Your advertisement here? Advertise with Caskable
Westland Peated Single Malt
The bottle
Westland Peated Single Malt
USA46% ABVNo age statement
Check price at retailer
18+ · Affiliate link · Prices may vary
Caskable score
73
out of 100
In this review
    The Caskable Weekly

    One email a week. Whisky worth knowing about.

    New reviews, distillery news and what is worth buying right now. No spam, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

    Read our privacy policy. Your email is used only to send the newsletter.