Four Roses Small Batch
- Caskable score 79/100
- About £33 (70 cl)
- 45% ABV
- USA
More fruit, more depth and a better score.

The Green River Kentucky Straight Bourbon review is for the bottle that does the plain job. It is the core bourbon of a revived Owensboro brand, bottled at 45 per cent in a 75 cl bottle for about £46, and it carries no age statement and no unusual finish. There is nothing to explain, so this should be a short review about a longer price.
I do not mind a plain bourbon. I mind paying a fancy price for one.
Green River is an old Kentucky brand, shut down with its distillery in the early 1990s, revived in Owensboro in the 2010s and now part of Bardstown Bourbon Company. The Green River distillery page has the dates and the owners, and the Full Proof sibling, which I scored 72, sits above it at 58.9 per cent.
This is the standard bottle, at 45 per cent. It is a Kentucky straight bourbon, which means at least two years in new charred oak, and I would assume it is a young one.
Corn sweetness, vanilla and a faint whiff of fresh oak shavings.
The nose is soft and sweet: corn and vanilla first, then caramel, a little cherry and a clean, fresh woodiness. There is a hint of cinnamon and a faint note of fresh bread. It is easy and slightly young.
The palate is smooth, sweet and fairly light, with caramel and vanilla at the front, a touch of cherry in the middle and a gentle, peppery spice from the oak. At 45 per cent it has just enough body. There is no great depth, and nothing is wrong.
The finish is short to medium: vanilla, a little spice, caramel and a clean, slightly dry fade.
What strikes me is how much it tastes like the average of every decent bourbon at this strength. It is clean, sweet and balanced, and I cannot tell you one thing about it that would make you choose it over a dozen others.
That is a fair description of a bourbon from a distillery that is still building its stocks and its identity. The Full Proof has more energy. This one has more manners.
A young brand’s core bottle has a hard job. It has to be affordable, consistent and recognisable all at once, and the Green River manages the first two. The third will come with age and a few more years of stock behind it.
Over one large cube, or with a splash of water, or in an Old Fashioned, where the sweetness and the soft oak work well. A whiskey highball with ginger ale is also a good use. I would not sip it neat for an hour.
At about £46 it scores 71. Old Forester 100 scores 76 at about £38, and Elijah Craig Small Batch scores 76 at about £40. Buffalo Trace scores 78 at about £26, and Four Roses Small Batch scores 79 at about £33.
The comparison is not close. Four better bourbons cost less, and two of them cost a good deal less. The Green River is a nice bottle and a hard sell.
If it is a decent bourbon at around forty-five pounds, or less, you want, these four are the ones I would take.
More fruit, more depth and a better score.
Rounder and richer, and twenty pounds less.
A 50 per cent bourbon for about thirty-eight.
A hotter, more energetic Green River at a higher price.
A clean, soft, slightly anonymous bourbon with a good story and a price that is too high. If you want to support a revival, buy the Full Proof. If you want a bargain, buy the Buffalo Trace.
Caskable score: 71 out of 100.
Corn sweetness, vanilla, caramel, a little cherry and fresh oak.
Smooth and fairly light, caramel and vanilla, a touch of cherry and gentle oak spice.
Short to medium. Vanilla, a little spice, caramel and a clean dry fade.
A clean, soft, rather anonymous bourbon that is dearer than better-known standards.
Thomas Grønvold is the founder of Caskable and a whisky enthusiast who believes the best way to learn about whisky is simply to drink it, compare it, and stay curious. From supermarket favourites to bottles from distilleries around the world, he writes about what he actually tastes and experiences, without pretending you need to be an expert to enjoy a good dram.
View profile →