Aberlour 12 Double Cask Matured
- Caskable score 81/100
- About £38 (70 cl)
- 40% ABV
- Scotland
Sherry and bourbon wood, and the best value of the lot.

This Tomintoul Pedro Ximenez Sherry Cask Finish review is about a good idea in a small glass. Pedro Ximenez is the darkest, sweetest, stickiest style of sherry, and it is used to finish whisky when someone wants richness, dried fruit and a long dessert note. It costs about £40 and it is bottled at 40 per cent.
I like PX finishes. I am less certain that 40 per cent can carry one.
Tomintoul calls itself the Gentle Dram, and the Tomintoul distillery page tells the story of the Glenlivet-area distillery and its mid-1960s build. The PX Finish is a no-age-statement bottle, finished in Pedro Ximenez sherry casks, and priced about a pound above the 10 Year Old.
The finish is the point, and the 40 per cent is the limit. Strength carries flavour, and a thick sweet cask asks for a good deal of it.
Raisins, treacle toffee and a faint smell of a Christmas cake in the next room.
The nose is sweet and fruity: raisins, sultanas, treacle toffee and a soft, honeyed sweetness, with a thin line of cinnamon and a little vanilla. It is richer than the 10, and a little cloying.
The palate is smooth and sweet, with dried fruit and toffee at the front and a gentle, sherried spice in the middle. The texture is soft and slightly syrupy, but it is thin, because the strength is low. The sweetness is the main thing, and it does not leave much room for anything else.
The finish is short to medium: raisin, toffee, a little spice and a sweet, rather sticky fade.
The finish has done what finishes do. It has added a thick layer of dried fruit and sugar. What it has not added is balance, because the underlying whisky is light and the sherry sits on top rather than inside it.
If you like a sweet, easy dram, it is a pleasant one, and I can see why it has a following. If you want your sherry with some structure, the 14 or a proper sherry-cask malt is a better route.
PX is the sherry that is sometimes poured over ice cream, and I mean that as a description of its consistency, not as a joke. A whisky finished in it needs enough body to push back, and the best examples are bottled at 46 per cent or more. At 40 per cent there is very little to push with.
Neat, with a drop of water, or over ice in a short glass, where the sweetness mellows and the dried fruit comes forward. It is a very good dessert whisky, and it does particularly well alongside dark chocolate or a good blue cheese.
At about £40 it scores 67. Tomintoul 10 scores 66 at about £39, and Tomintoul 14 scores 74 at about £58. Aberlour 12 Double Cask scores 81 at about £38, and GlenAllachie 12 scores 80 at about £44.
The sherry comparison is brutal. Two properly sherried Speysiders beat the Tomintoul by thirteen points and fourteen points, for the same money. The PX Finish is a single point better than the 10 and a long way from the best sherry bottles.
If it is sherry richness at about forty pounds that you want, these four are far stronger options.
Sherry and bourbon wood, and the best value of the lot.
A sherried Speysider at 46 per cent, for four pounds more.
A fruitier, cleaner sherried malt at about fifty.
More strength and more depth for about eighteen pounds more.
A sweet, soft, sherried Tomintoul that is easy to enjoy and thin beside the real sherry bottles. It is a nice dessert whisky and nothing more. Buy the Aberlour.
Caskable score: 67 out of 100.
Raisins, sultanas, treacle toffee, honeyed sweetness and a thread of cinnamon.
Smooth and sweet, dried fruit and toffee, gentle sherried spice and a thin, syrupy body.
Short to medium. Raisin, toffee, a little spice and a sweet sticky fade.
A very sweet PX-finished Speysider that is pleasant but too thin at 40 per cent.
Thomas Grønvold is the founder of Caskable and a whisky enthusiast who believes the best way to learn about whisky is simply to drink it, compare it, and stay curious. From supermarket favourites to bottles from distilleries around the world, he writes about what he actually tastes and experiences, without pretending you need to be an expert to enjoy a good dram.
View profile →