Tomintoul 10 Year Old
- Caskable score 66/100
- About £39
- 40% ABV
- Scotland
Lighter and thinner, and about nineteen pounds cheaper.

Tomintoul 14 Year Old is the bottle that fixes the problem I had with the 10. At 46 per cent and about £58 it is a more serious whisky than its 40 per cent younger sibling, and this Tomintoul 14 Year Old review is mostly about how much more serious.
It also has a world record attached to it, which is the sort of thing I enjoy more than I should.
Tomintoul is the Speyside distillery in the Glenlivet area that calls its whisky the Gentle Dram, and the Tomintoul distillery page has the story of the mid-1960s build, the two sets of stills and the Ballantruan spring. The 14 is bottled at 46 per cent, a stronger and fuller version of the house style.
In 2009 the distillery produced a 105.3 litre bottle of the 14 Year Old, which was recognised as the largest bottle of whisky in the world. It is a splendid piece of nonsense, and I like that the distillery chose the 14 for it.
Honeycomb, orchard fruit and a dry, nutty oak.
The nose is soft and sweet: honeycomb, ripe pear, green apple and vanilla, with a trace of toasted nuts and a hint of cereal. It is richer than the 10, and a little more grown-up.
The palate is smooth and quite creamy. Honey and pear come first, then a gentle baking spice, some malt and a dry, nutty oak. At 46 per cent the body is fuller and the flavours are clearer. It is still a gentle whisky, and it is no longer a thin one.
The finish is medium: honey, malt, a little spice and a clean, slightly dry fade. It is a more satisfying finish than the 10’s by some distance.
The big difference from the 10 is strength, and I think it matters more than the four years. A gentle whisky at 40 per cent is a bit insubstantial. The same whisky at 46 per cent has room to show what it is.
That makes the 14 the first Tomintoul I would recommend without hesitation. It is not remarkable, and it does everything it sets out to.
It is also the first Tomintoul where the distillery character, a clean, grassy, honeyed style, is allowed to speak for itself instead of being politely ironed flat. That is what the extra strength and the extra years have bought.
Neat, with a few drops of water, in a tulip glass. It is a good whisky for a quiet evening and one that suits somebody who likes light, fruity, easy drams. I would not add ice, and a highball would be a waste of the extra strength.
At about £58 it scores 74. Tomintoul 10 scores 66 at about £39. The Glenlivet 12 scores 75 at about £36, and Aberfeldy 12 scores 75 at about £38. Glen Moray 15 scores 75 at about £58, and Balblair 15 scores 79 at about £74.
So the Tomintoul is a good step up from its own 10, and it is dearer than a couple of younger rivals that score one point higher. That is not a disaster. It is a reason to pay attention to what you want. That is a fair result, and a fair price to pay for it.
If it is a gentle, fruity Highland or Speyside malt at around fifty pounds, these four are the ones I would line up.
Lighter and thinner, and about nineteen pounds cheaper.
A point better and about twenty pounds less.
A fuller, sweeter Highland malt for less.
A richer fifteen year old for about sixteen pounds more.
A gentle, honeyed, much more convincing Tomintoul that fixes the 10’s weaknesses. It is a pleasant, easy whisky at a price that could be lower.
Caskable score: 74 out of 100.
Honeycomb, ripe pear, green apple, vanilla and toasted nuts.
Smooth and creamy, honey and pear, baking spice, malt and dry nutty oak.
Medium. Honey, malt, a little spice and a clean dry fade.
A gentle, honeyed Speysider that is a clear improvement on the 10 but priced above better rivals.
Thomas Grønvold is the founder of Caskable and a whisky enthusiast who believes the best way to learn about whisky is simply to drink it, compare it, and stay curious. From supermarket favourites to bottles from distilleries around the world, he writes about what he actually tastes and experiences, without pretending you need to be an expert to enjoy a good dram.
View profile →